Happy Halloween! If you want to go through the thrill of a harmless nightmare, then when not try to get your hands on one of the above products? I double dare you! The promised restocks by Nintendo on launch day were sold out within seconds again and scalpers are having a pay day. Nintendo has completely underestimated the demand for this 40th Anniversary collection and even admitted in doing so (see GamesRadar), so what exactly went wrong?
Well, special edition hardware pieces around The Legend of Zelda have been problematic in different ways for over a decade now, which has created this weird sine and cosine curve relationship of what Nintendo anticipates and what fans actually want. And I'm not sure they will break out of this cycle any time soon.
It basically started with the Nintendo 3DS, where they overdid things. There were more Zelda-themed editions for the Nintendo 3DS family than actual Zelda games. At first, each of these provided a meaningful upgrade, from a Nintendo 3DS to a Nintendo 3DS XL and then to a New Nintendo 3DS XL. But things got weird and even nonsensical with the "Hyrule Edition" of the New 3DS XL and the "Hylian Shield Edition" of the New 2DS XL. Nintendo did not stop making these Zelda editions, creating a bubble that would burst.
Naturally, the demand became lower and lower, but Nintendo took this "insight" into the Nintendo Switch era. Well, whatever their reasons were, they refused to make another Zelda edition for years, which has caused some confusion and internal conflict amongst the Zelda fans who were anticipating such a thing. You can even find an article about this topic here on this blog, from the time when the Link's Awakening remake was about to be released:
Where is the Nintendo Switch Zelda Edition? (September 2019)
You had to wait a total of six years for a Zelda edition to arrive, which was the one for Tears of the Kingdom in April 2023. I know only of a single Zelda fan out there who has actually been this patient; everyone else already bought a Nintendo Switch. At least the OLED model provided an upgrade of some sorts, but it still didn't sell as much as Nintendo had hoped.
And this shouldn't be a surprise. The target audience for Tears of the Kingdom was players who have enjoyed Breath of the Wild to its fullest and who wanted more of that. And while the game also had a Wii U version, 95% of that player base was on Nintendo Switch already. So, as a result, these Tears of the Kingdom Editions sat on shelves for months. And that's not something Nintendo likes to see, that's for sure.
But things became even worse with their next "Hyrule Edition", which was about as pointless as the first. One year later, for the launch of Echoes of Wisdom, they released a golden Nintendo Switch Lite... Because that's the thing Zelda fans really needed in the final year of the Nintendo Switch. I'm not joking when I say that I can still go to a media store today and potentially find one of these. They have been that unpopular.
And that golden Switch Lite is not even bad, just too little, too late. If this had come out together with Link's Awakening back in 2019, then this would have seen the proper demand. Heck, I probably would have used this as my primary way of playing Switch games for a little while, until Age of Calamity at least.
Now, the best course of action was to release such a special edition earlier for the Nintendo Switch 2. And they did. They made one for the 40th Anniversary, which even could be anticipated by the fans, right before the launch of the remake of one of the most beloved Zelda games, and one of most beloved games of all time. It wasn't entirely ideal, because they also released a new Hyrule Warriors game last year, but it's somewhat understandable that they wanted to wait for Ocarina of Time, especially with how popular this remake has become.
However, this was not the only conclusion Nintendo had here after the Nintendo Switch. They also saw a shrinking demand for Zelda-themed hardware in general and may have adjusted their projections accordingly for their 40th Anniversary collection. If they have produced 500,000 of the Tears of the Kingdom OLEDs back in 2023, then they might have reduced this to 200,000 for the 40th Anniversary Edition. These number are just freely made up, of course, but it's the mindset of "better have a sellout than to overproduce". They don't want to see "Latest Zelda editions collecting dust on store shelves" in the headlines again.
But if there is too much of a shortage, then the headlines won't be positive either. If you are fan who really wanted the 40th Anniversary Switch 2 for the Ocarina of Time remake, then you might be out of luck. And now you have to make a choice between getting a plain Nintendo Switch 2 or buying from a scalper on ebay. Either way, you lose. Or you wait until the new, big 3D Zelda game gets released in two to three years, because that's likely where the whole cycle repeats itself for a turn.
Nintendo has now learned that there is still a big demand for these Zelda editions, much to their own surprise... So, they might decide to release another one for the next Zelda game and adjust the projections accordingly once more, only then to overproduce again, because they didn't think about all the Zelda fans who have bought such a system for the 40th Anniversary already and are not in need of another.
Funnily enough, with these Zelda editions there is only really one system where Nintendo did it right: the Wii U, their most unsuccessful home console. But you got a Zelda edition in its first year for the first Zelda release – The Wind Waker HD, it was easy enough to find one of these, and it was the only Zelda edition for the Wii U. It wasn't the prettiest, but it was handled in the right way.
That's not going to happen with the Switch 2, because it's potentially going to receive other models in the future – a Nintendo Switch 2 Lite, or a Nintendo Switch 2 OLED model, where each of these could see a Zelda edition of their own at the end. And this may even produce another "Hyrule Edition" nobody asked for, starting the cycle all over again.










































